Bookmark this independent blog

Friday, 15 February 2013

Oxenhope turbine refused permission

A planning application for a small wind turbine at Bodkin Lane, Oxenhope has been refused by Bradford MDC.  Three reasons are given, the first being that "The proposed development would introduce an incongruous and widely visible vertical element into this sensitive upland landscape within the Worth Valley, whose historical and literary associations are also central to its wider economic value in tourism terms.  The proposed turbine would be seen from a number of vantage points and would result in significant harm to the character of the landscape that would outweigh its limited contribution towards overall renewable energy targets......"
This is just what campaigners connected to the Brontë Society have been saying in objections over the last year.  Ironically, this is one turbine which was not mentioned by the Society. Meanwhile, the really gigantic ones have got the go-ahead.


In January of this year a planning application to erect three micro-scale wind turbines in Oxenhope parish was submitted to Bradford Metropolitan District Council.  Because of the location of the proposed turbines which, close to Penistone Hill, would have been clearly visible numerous vantage points, the Brontë Society submitted an objection to Bradford Metropolitan District Council in accordance with our Heritage & Conservation Policy.

I am pleased to report that planning permission for the turbines has been refused on the grounds that the development would introduce ‘incongruous’ structures into ‘this sensitive rural landscape whose historical and literary associations are also central to its wider economic value in tourist terms.  The proposed turbines would be seen from vantage points and public rights of way over a wide area and would result in significant harm to the character of the landscape that would outweigh the limited contribution towards overall renewable energy targets.’  A further reason for refusal was that the turbines would be ‘an encroachment of inappropriate  development into the Green Belt that would have a harmful effect on the openness of the Green Belt’ and, again, it was felt that the negative impact outweighed the benefits as a source of renewable energy.

This is the third such planning application which has been refused by Bradford MDC on these grounds and it is very gratifying to know that the value of this unique heritage landscape has been recognised in the planning process.

Christine Went
Heritage and Conservation Officer

Saturday, 9 February 2013

Historic Redecoration

Yesterday, two hundred (or was it more?) people crowded into the Old Schoolroom opposite the Parsonage to eat from a sumptuous buffet, drink wine and meet friends from the Brontë Society and interested members of the public. After brief speeches - from Sally McDonald, Chair of Brontë Society Council, Deputy Lord Lieutenant Terence Suthers and Professor Ann Sumner, the new Executive Director, the crowd split into groups to cross the narrow road and enter the Museum to see for themselves.

In the photo - Ann Sumner and Sally McDonald.

All of the refurbishments are historically accurate, the transformed Parsonage representing the culmination of two and a half years of painstaking analysis, using up-to-date forensic techniques. In summer, 2010, the University of Lincoln and historic design consultant Allyson McDermott were approached by the Parsonage to begin an analysis of the available evidence, with a view to coming up with a new, more historically accurate scheme of redecoration.

As well as historical and scientific analysis, a wide range of contemporary sources, including watercolours and letters by the Brontës, was also referenced. This rigorous £60,000 programme has informed the creation of bespoke wallpapers, new curtains and painstakingly woven rugs.

It was all there as we looked around, without some of the curtains, which will be coming soon to add the finishing touches. To give a few examples, Mr Brontë's Study has been distempered in plain white, because no evidence could be found that it was ever papered, and the Dining Room now follows Charlotte's own decorative scheme from the early 1850s. The curtains are still in the process of being specially woven, in crimson, to match Elizabeth Gaskell's description. According to forensic analysis, the room was papered both before and after Charlotte's 'gentrification', and the chosen paper is a contemporary design, in scarlet to match the curtains. Several years ago, a scrap of wallpaper was found in Branwell's Studio which can now be dated to the Brontë period. Allyson McDermott matched it with an almost identical sample - also contemporaneous with the Brontës' time - which was found inside a housemaid's cupboard at Kensington Palace. The wallpaper has been reproduced.

So visitors in the coming season can look forward to an even better experience.

Saturday, 2 February 2013

Re-Visioning the Brontës Conference

Richard Wilcocks reports:
The Re-Visioning the Brontës Conference took place on 29 January in The Brotherton Room, which holds about fifty people comfortably. Attached to Special Collections in Leeds University’s Brotherton Library, it has plenty of atmosphere, with oak columns and panels, proximity to rare Brontë manuscripts and a presiding bust of a big-whiskered Lord Brotherton. It has been used on occasion, I was told, for the telling of ghost stories, which seemed to be an appropriate fact to bear in mind during the conference, in which one of the unofficial keywords was ‘afterlife’.

Conference Organiser Nick Cass from the School of Fine Art, History of Art and Cultural Studies, spoke to us first, and it was soon clear that the acoustics of the place are not perfect : people sitting on the periphery found it hard to hear, especially if the speaker did not project in their direction. Listening to David Wilson’s tenor saxophone was no problem, though. He played beautifully while we looked at Simon Warner’s evocative landscape photographs on a large pull-down screen – Top Withins shrouded in mist, a watery sun over Stanbury -  a mood-setting show which was followed by Jane Sellars, once at the Parsonage, now Curator of Art at the Mercer Art Gallery in Harrogate. She delivered a useful historical overview of the fluctuating fortunes of the Museum, drawing attention to the effects of films on attendance and pointing out that it was “extraordinary the amount of material which has come to light in the last twenty years or so – a substantial number of items have emerged from the shadows”.

Dr Carl Plasa from Cardiff University, in ‘Southern Flight: Brontëan Migrations in Kate Chopin’s At Fault’ spoke about Chopin’s “neglected novel” of the late nineteenth century and the transatlantic afterlife of Jane Eyre, bringing in many references to contemporary assumptions about “white creole degeneracy” and the way in which Chopin had challenged these assumptions in her novel, which is set in Louisiana and packed full of characters who speak French, Spanish and Creole in addition to English. His enlightening hand-out (‘Prefigurements and Afterlives: Bertha Mason’s Literary Histories’)  drew parallels between Charlotte Brontë’s description of Bertha in Jane Eyre, Juanna Trista, a ‘pensionnaire’ in The Professor and a mentally ‘incompetent’ wife (alcoholic) in At Fault. To my surprise, at least, he made just one fleeting reference to Jean Rhys’s Wide Sargasso Sea.

Amber Pouliot from Leeds University, (‘Righting the Life of the Mind: The Significance of Psychological Discourse in the Brontës’ Interwar Afterlives’) spoke about an emphasis by critics on Charlotte for most of the nineteenth century which shifted to Emily to some extent in the early twentieth century, when she might have been seen as a model of a ‘new woman’, attitudes to mental illness to be found in the frameworks of nineteenth century belief, and comments by twentieth century commentators who were influenced by psychoanalytical theories which, ironically, originated in Gaskell’s view of Charlotte and the Brontës.

Aislinn Hunter from Edinburgh University  began her lecture, which was illustrated by slides, with references to the ancient manuscripts of Timbuktu which some people thought might all have been burned by Islamist extremists (apparently some of them were successfully hidden) because she had much to say, in ‘The Brontës, Materiality and Resonance: Three Ways of Looking’ about original artefacts and documents and “the resonances which they give off”. These depend on context (for example in a museum), on foreknowledge and on tradition to a large extent, but also on the way our brains work: specialized parts of this organ deal with memory and with our perceptions of beauty and truth. She did not quote from Keats, but she did give us a brief overview of the way neurons behaved. Her illustrations on the screen included works by Victoria Brookland and Cornelia Parker – “…an encounter with the artist and with the artist who had the encounter with the Brontës”.

Sarah Prescott, who is Literary Archivist in Special Collections, introduced us to the Brontë manuscripts which are kept there, giving us a potted history of how they were acquired: we saw images of journalist, critic and collector Clement Shorter, the one who found so much that had been wrapped up in newspaper at the bottom of the Reverend Nicholls’s wardrobe and, amongst others, the outrageous Thomas James Wise, who became infamous for literary forgeries and for dealing out manuscripts like a deck of cards

‘”…like a new picture introduced to the gallery of memory”: Re-Visioning Jane Eyre through Paula Rego’ was the title for Dr Sarah Wooton from Durham University. Handed-out papers contained several reproductions of Rego’s lithographs, and Dr Wooton’s commentaries on them formed the basis of her lecture: “It is not always clear how Rego’s pictures relate to Jane Eyre… who doesn’t always appear to be the same person in different depictions… how can Rego picture a heroine who is reluctant to picture herself?… she tries to depict the ‘plain Jane’ we have come to know through reading..”

‘Charlotte’s Dress’ was a presentation by Lisa Sheppy, who graduated with an MA in Multi-Disciplinary Printmaking at UWE, Bristol in 2009 with a distinction and based her research on the development of enamel printmaking and warm glass processes. She told us how a visit to the Parsonage had caused a great change of direction in her interests. She had been encouraged while she was there to make drawings in her sketch book – of items like Charlotte’s gloves and bonnet – and had been inspired to make an imaginary wedding dress – “a sort of ghost dress. It was constructed by myself and my mother, who had worked as a professional dressmaker…  the crinoline hoops are showing through…it’s like a cage…”

Dr Richard Brown from the University of Leeds’s English Department was in conversation with Professor Blake Morrison from Goldsmiths, University of London on Morrison’s play We Are Three Sisters, which was shown at the Viaduct Theatre in Halifax, performed by Northern Broadsides, in September 2011 (see this blog’s review here) before touring. Intelligently and wittily, Morrison managed to use Chekhov’s Three Sisters as a template, which involved some squeezing and shoving (for example, having Mrs Robinson actually staying at the Parsonage and bringing on a William Weightman character years after his death) but which resulted in a very watchable play. Morrison explained the problems involved in pursuing a personal project which dated back many years.

Dr Jenny Bavidge, lecturer at Cambridge University, showed clips with music. “The name ‘Wuthering’ invites an auditory experience,” she said, in ‘Listening Out: the Soundtracks and Film Scores of Wuthering Heights.’ Is music too blunt an instrument? Does it elicit too much of a Pavlovian response? We watched extracts from the William Wyler version from 1939 – music all the way through, for everything. ‘Cathy’s Theme’ makes the film “Cathy-centric”. We saw Merle Oberon’s Cathy standing in front of a window for her declaration of shared identity with Heathcliff – with not just the music but a clap of thunder. Then there was the Peter Kosminsky version – an edgier sound, Irish connections, and Bunuel’s Abismos de Pasion (1954) with its use of Wagner’s Tristan und Isolde… but what we did not see an extract of was Andrea Arnold’s version, where there is practically no music (although the Young Cathy does sing Barbara Allen) but plenty of wind.

Maria Seijo-Richart from the University of A Coruña showed us clips and stills as well, for ‘Wuthering Heights in Japan: the film Arashi ga Oka (1988, directed by Yoshishige Yoshida)’. She explained how Japanese film-makers relate Western classics (for example Macbeth) to Japanese theatre traditions and storytelling techniques. It was fascinating to hear how the Noh Theatre influenced the director – the orphan Onimaru is looked after by a group of priests who worship a Mountain of Fire and who try to appease gods of anger. He is in love with Kinu, beautiful daughter of a local family… and she later dies in childbirth.

Towards the end of the day, a roundtable discussion chaired by Adam Strickson, Teaching Fellow in Creative Writing at Leeds University, did not seem to last very long, making many of those present think that the conference should have had more time allocated to it. Perhaps the next one – let’s hope for a next one – will be for two days.

The new Director of the Brontë Parsonage Museum, Ann Sumner, brought the proceedings to a close with some well-chosen remarks and an overview of the main areas covered.

The conference was organized through the Centre for Critical Studies in Museums, Galleries & Heritage and the Stanley & Audrey Burton Gallery, and was funded by CCI Exchange – the University of Leeds Higher Education Innovation Fund.